Recurring Nightmare Exodus Rare Magic card — value and price

Recurring Nightmare

Exodus · Rare
Magic mtg:c8173030-1c33-417c-b8e9-79231b6a85a7 TCGplayer + Cardmarket
Fair market value
$75.75
Consensus of 2 market price guides. Typical $59.58 – $94.03.
→ 1% · 49d
Sources: TCGplayer + Cardmarket · Near Mint, raw
Optimal buy
$70.22
Never pay above $73.26
Optimal sell
$80.94
Never sell below $77.31
≈ $65.02 in hand after fees & shipping

These are marketplace prices — what a card trades at between collectors on eBay, TCGplayer or Cardmarket. A local shop buying for cash pays well under this, and that isn't a bad offer: they carry the rent, the staff and the risk of stock that may sit for a year. Store credit usually beats their cash price.

Buy this card · aim to pay under $73.26
Buy this card on TCGplayer →Find on eBay →Graded (PSA 10) →Amazon: sealed →
When it arrives: a penny sleeve + toploader is all it takes to keep it Near Mint.
Penny sleevesToploaders

We may earn a commission on purchases — at no extra cost to you, and it never affects our valuations.

</> Embed this card / add a value badge
SplitShot value badge
Badge — HTML<a href="https://splitshot.co/card/mtg:c8173030-1c33-417c-b8e9-79231b6a85a7"><img src="https://splitshot.co/badge/mtg:c8173030-1c33-417c-b8e9-79231b6a85a7.svg" alt="SplitShot value"></a>
Badge — Markdown[![SplitShot value](https://splitshot.co/badge/mtg:c8173030-1c33-417c-b8e9-79231b6a85a7.svg)](https://splitshot.co/card/mtg:c8173030-1c33-417c-b8e9-79231b6a85a7)
Widget — iframe<iframe src="https://splitshot.co/embed/mtg:c8173030-1c33-417c-b8e9-79231b6a85a7" width="360" height="172" style="border:0;overflow:hidden" loading="lazy" title="SplitShot value"></iframe>

Free to use anywhere — forum signatures, blogs, wikis. The value updates automatically. Note: eBay's listing policy allows externally-hosted images but not links off-site, so use the badge image alone there, without the link.

On Discord, skip the snippets entirely — add the SplitShot app and type /value in any channel.

Selling this card
Optimal sell $80.94 · never below $77.31. Value your copy for the live net-after-fees calculator.
Where to sell
eBay~13.25% + $0.30Largest audience; on any listing use “Sell one like this” to prefill yours.TCGplayer~10–11%Best for singles; buyers expect competitive, data-driven pricing.
Shipping & protection supplies
Sleeve + toploader in a team bag, taped inside a bubble mailer, shipped with tracking.
Penny sleevesToploadersTeam bagsBubble mailersPainter’s tape

Amazon Business Free to join and gives bulk pricing on sleeves, toploaders and mailers — worth it if you ship cards often.

Related cards
Survival of the Fittest cardSurvival of the FittestExodus$444.24Hatred cardHatredExodus$64.90City of Traitors cardCity of TraitorsExodus$553.14Mind Over Matter cardMind Over MatterExodus$48.85Selvala, Heart of the Wilds cardSelvala, Heart of the WildsCommander Masters$82.66Jeweled Lotus cardJeweled LotusCommander Masters$82.72
More Exodus →
Common questions
How much is Recurring Nightmare worth?

Recurring Nightmare from Exodus has a fair market value of about $75.75 (Near Mint, raw), based on a consensus of current market price guides.

What is the best price to sell Recurring Nightmare?

List around $80.94 to clear without leaving money on the table; that nets about $65.02 after fees and shipping.

What should I pay to buy Recurring Nightmare?

A disciplined buy target is about $70.22 — a discount to fair value that keeps an edge. Aim not to pay above $73.26.

Where can I buy Recurring Nightmare?

Recurring Nightmare is sold on eBay, TCGplayer, and Amazon. Compare live listings against the fair value of $75.75 and aim to pay under $73.26 — SplitShot links you straight to current listings at each marketplace.

Is now a good time to buy Recurring Nightmare?

Recurring Nightmare is trending stable lately. A disciplined entry is under $73.26; paying near or below $70.22 keeps a margin of safety versus the $75.75 fair value.

Estimate for guidance, not an appraisal. Value your exact copy →