Subtlety card values & prices

Every Subtlety printing we track in Magic, ranked by market value (approx., as of 2026-07-20). Tap any card for its live value, optimal buy & sell prices, and a 1-year forecast.

Across 2 Magic printings we track, Subtlety ranges from $43.87 to $821.77.

Subtlety Secret Lair Drop card priceSubtletySecret Lair Drop$821.77Buy on eBay →
Subtlety Special Guests card priceSubtletySpecial Guests$43.87Buy on eBay →
See this week's biggest Magic price movers →
Common questions
How much is Subtlety worth?

Subtlety ranges from $43.87 to $821.77 across the 2 Magic printings we track. The most valuable is the Secret Lair Drop printing at about $821.77. Tap any printing for its live value and optimal buy/sell prices.

Which Subtlety card is most valuable?

The Secret Lair Drop printing, at about $821.77. Values move with condition, grade, and the specific set.

Why do Subtlety prices vary so much?

Different printings — base set, holo, alternate art, promos — plus condition and professional grade (e.g., PSA 10) can swing value many times over. Each printing below links to its own live valuation.